53 Comments

My favorite president is anyone not named Trump...

Expand full comment
author

Amen.

Expand full comment
Feb 18·edited Feb 18Liked by Michael Estrin

F(*&&^! brilliant! I'm still laughing. And, obviously, Martin van Buren is by far our best president. https://christinastravels.substack.com/p/martin-van-who

Expand full comment
author

This is so cool, Christina! I’d love to do something like this one day.

Expand full comment
Feb 18Liked by Michael Estrin

Thanks for the wave, Michael! You are such a pal! This Telemarketer Theatre is a work of true art! Be careful--you might have that telemarketer calling you on the regular for the entertainment factor. Wait--did you just reboot the Jerky Boys? Take my Kickstarter money. President Harrison's Mom was all "Henry! Put on a hat! Here, this one that MeeMaw knitted for you. Take it! It has duckies on it! Put it on! HENRY! Don't you give me that look! Where are your mittens? HENRY!" This version of history is supported by 90% of historians under the age of 8.

Expand full comment
author

Your version of history tracks. The kids know the truth.

Expand full comment
Feb 18Liked by Michael Estrin

If I had my way we'd have at least one 8-year-old in every congressional department. They aren't afraid to say, "Steve, your plan is DOODIE! WHO WANTS ICE CREAM FOR LUNCH?" This is what Whitney meant when she said to let the children lead the way...

Expand full comment
Feb 18Liked by Michael Estrin

Hahaha this was really good! I love the ending. Perfect punchline, Alex! You did not throw away your shot

Expand full comment

1. Robert Redford in Watchmen.

2. Real men choose death over suitable attire.

3. Seemingly, otherwise you'd think they'd give up.

4. Reagan. Always blame Reagan.

5. Bookstores and libraries. And, definitely.

Expand full comment
author

This comment reminds me that Redford has range. He can play a president, but he can also play a guy who took down a president.

Expand full comment

As a professional historian, I should have one, but simply can't choose. But my favorite way to deal with telemarketers who start out asking if I am Mrs. (husband's name) is to say. "No, but I'm (husband's name)'s wife. (I was one of those feminists who kept her own name, way back in 1972). This always got confused silence. Then if I was feeling particularly snarky, and after my mothe-in-law's death, I would say, "No, she's dead." Now that I am older and kinder, I just say. "No." Thanks again for the morning laugh.

Expand full comment
author

As man married to a woman who kept her name, I love this comment.

Expand full comment

The story I always tell is going into work, a small clinic, and telling people I was getting married in a few months (we were already living together) and the first thing they asked was my new name and to see the ring (I said our decision was either we both get rings, or neither---so decision was neither) the immediate, spontaneous reaction was, "then why are you getting married!" I had to zip my lip not to exclaim, "Not to get a new name and a ring!" Since that was 55 years ago, and I am still married to the man who had no objection to me keeping my name and not wanting a ring to declare I was his property, you might say I made a very good decision. (smile)

Expand full comment
author

It sounds like you made a very good decision indeed.

Christina and I got married in 2011. I was kinda surprised that so many people thought she should take my name. I mean, it was 2011 and we were still having this debate?? Of course, it’s 2024 and people still think like this. It’s bonkers. But we always have a laugh when Christina makes hotel reservations and they call me by her last name.

Expand full comment

1. John Quincy Adams. His actual presidential term wasn't much, but then he went into Congress and was absolutely brilliant. Argued the Amistad case, supported the Smithsonian, presented civizen petitions arguing for abolition of slavery in the District of Columbia and when the House imposed a gag rule so he'd stop doing that, he fought that like hell until they repealed the rule. #JQAFTW.

2. Look, you know how it is, you're rushing to get ready for your presidential inauguration and you just forget, okay? What's the worst that can happen? It's not like you're going to catch a cold and die a month later, right?

3. Once in my wild college days I donated something to one of those scam-PACs after they called and kept bugging me. Never doing that again. Yeesh.

4. William Henry Harrison, in his last official act.

5. Not much, but absolutely yes. All weekends should be three-day. Mondays are the worst.

Expand full comment
author

I need to learn more about John Quincy Adams. Thanks for the info! Any good books you can recommend?

Expand full comment

Well, David McCullough's book John Adams includes some material about JQA, which if I remember right, but really the main book I read was by Harlow Giles Unger. https://www.amazon.com/Quincy-Adams-Harlow-Giles-Unger/dp/0306822652

That should be a good one to start with. (The chapter on the presidency was maybe a half hour on audiobook at best, which says a lot.)

Expand full comment
author

Thanks for the rec!

Expand full comment
Feb 18Liked by Michael Estrin

I’m fascinated with Chester A. Arthur. He was on the ticket to represent the grifty patronage faction of the Republican party with James Garfield leading the ticket as a reformer. When Garfield was killed, the expectation was that Arthur would turn America into a crony-ocracy, but he turned on his old bosses and passed significant anti-corruption reforms.

Expand full comment
author

Well, now I need to find a book about Chester A Arthur.

Expand full comment
Feb 18Liked by Michael Estrin

HILARIOUS! My husband and dog are wondering why I am sitting here laughing out loud at 6:30 a.m. It is tremendous fun to mess with telemarketers. I once, for no particular reason, started singing “Tomorrow, tomorrow, I love ya, tomorrow…” to a telemarketer. He kept on with his script without missing a beat. Kudos to Bob from Boise for outlasting me.

Expand full comment
author

I LOVE the singing response! Bravo!

Expand full comment
Feb 20Liked by Michael Estrin

I never bought anything from a telemarketer, but I did have one who called back to swear at me because I listened to his long spiel because I couldn't figure out what he was selling, then told him I wasn't interested and hung up on him.

I always thought President's Day was the appliance sale day, not the Mattress Sale holiday, But, if it was, the Mattress King must be Larry Miller of Sit N Sleep's "You're Killing Me, Larry" fame. And he seemed to have a new sale every few weeks,

Expand full comment
author

Mattress Kings, President's Day Mattress sales, I think we're on to something: the mattress is a symbol of leadership.

Expand full comment
Feb 19Liked by Michael Estrin

All weekends should def be 3 days. There’s a whole Reddit thread dedicated to messing with phone scammers - I love it. I can’t imagine being a telemarketer though.

Expand full comment
author

I can't imagine being a telemarketer either. But there was a show on Comedy Central called Workaholics about three telemarketers that was awesome.

Expand full comment
Feb 19Liked by Michael Estrin

☺️

Expand full comment

I feel like the 31% discount could also be a “thankful for modern medicine and not dying from common colds” celebration …

Expand full comment
author

Thank goodness for that!

Expand full comment
Feb 19Liked by Michael Estrin

I'm intelligent and mature and although I live in the UK I've visited the USA many times. BUT, I'd never heard of Presidents Day until this year. Can you believe it? For how many years has this holiday been celebrated, Michael?

Expand full comment
author

According to Wikipedia it's been a federal holiday since 1879. It started as Washington's birthday, then we added Lincoln, and now it's sorta for all of them, but really nobody cares. It's just an excuse for a three-day weekend and sales.

Expand full comment
Feb 20Liked by Michael Estrin

That's the sort of info I love. Thanks, Michael.

Expand full comment
Feb 18Liked by Michael Estrin

🤣😂 i bet you were the funnest call they had that day!

Expand full comment
author

I sure hope so.

Expand full comment
Feb 18Liked by Michael Estrin

1. Grant made life difficult for slavers and partied. What else can I ask for?

2. His name had natural gravity, even without the office and hilarious death. Why give that to a tailor for free? He was holding out for the highest bidder.

3. I haven’t met my match yet. Not that I’m some kind of genius, I’m just tired of every phone call seven seconds in.

4. A miracle worker. I go through one mattress every two decades, so it’s impressive to see them thrive.

5. My work schedule is detached from consensus reality.

Expand full comment
author

Grant gets something of a raw deal, thanks to the lost cause propaganda. He was a damn good general, not a butcher. And he was a better president than people realize. Why did we let the losers write history on this one?

Expand full comment

It's odd. I didn't think textbooks had consolation prizes.

Expand full comment
author

Sometimes I wonder if the Lost Cause narrative was the first participation trophy.

Expand full comment